Create a chance that players can be beaten unconscious with melee weapons & then captured using rope or duct tape & blindfolded with ripped sheets ect. Idk how to make it not unfair, but maybe you can think something up. Perhaps a player can try to break free somehow. Captured players can be imprisoned & or killed for meat. Captured players corpses could be impaled at your base & an option to severe the heads & display them on poles as warnings or as trophies at your base. Resorting to cannibalism. Maybe add an attribute of Lunatic would help you get enjoyment from eating your victims reducing boredom? Idk you flesh it out...