40.43 (Steam) Strange chance of something count.
0

5 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

I've tried to learn mechanics today.

And I got some strange results:

1) Chance to dismantle/put back a part 50% - takes me about 5-6 attempts to dismantle or put back a part. 2 critical (quality gone down from 100 to 83)

2) Chance 35% - took me 11-13 attempts. 4 critical (quality gone down from 100 to 73)

3) Chance 5% - didn't even tried to. Last time I've tried, the part gone from 100% to "Broken" on criticals and still wasn't dismantled.

 

So my guess is the chances counts some totally wrong way. With 50% I'd need 2 maybe 3 attempts. Not 5.

With a chance of 35% I'd need a 3-5 attempts. Not 12.

 

And, in advance of someone say "bad luck" - it's not. I've tried out about 10 different parts. The count is the same: 5-6 and 10+.

 

P.S. Hydrocraft mod is here. But I doubt it can interfere a game core.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Think of it like flipping a coin:

It can be heads or tails. You have a 50% chance each time you flip, yet you can have several flips in a row where you either get only heads or tails. It's only when the sample size is large enough that it actually approaches 1:2. That, ofc, is with a hypothetical coin - one that is perfectly balanced.  In practice, using a computer, the random number generator will have an implicit bias towards a particular distribution, favouring some numbers more than others, regardless of what the stated probability is. Kind of like a real-world coin - imperfections make it more likely to fall one way or the other.


So, it gets weird. (Assuming there isn't a bug with the calc, anyway.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah. I know how randomizer works. And I know math. :)

Actually I'm a graduated engineer-programmer.

 

So, that's why I've checked it continuously before starting this case.

I've took a car and started to dismantle and put back parts. With 0 level on mechanics all I can do is to take off the wheels and door windows (50% and 35% chances accordingly).

Count on tries to take off wheels: 5,6,4,1

Count on tries to put wheels back: 4,3,5,5

Count on tries to take off windows: 10,8,2,7

Count on tries to put windows back: 7,3,11,14

 

Out of what I can see - chances are NOT like the game shows me.

And I doubt the randomizer can work like this. I mean give a lower values THIS many times in a row.

IDK how to investigate it further. Can try to check up the code myself, tho...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

After some more investigations I should add:

Even with a skill way higher than required (3 actual vs. 1 needed for example), character still manages to damage parts on detach/attach operations. But the chance of it virtually is 0.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
0